Understanding Commercial Leases: Finding the Best Type, Costs, Length, and Landlord Obligations

A commercial lease is a legal agreement allowing a business tenant to occupy and use a property for commercial purposes in exchange for paying rent to the landlord. Choosing the best type of commercial lease is critical—this decision can influence a tenant’s operational stability, cost management, and long-term success. Similarly, from the landlord’s perspective, structuring an appropriate lease is essential for securing reliable rental income, minimising disputes, and maintaining the property’s value.

This article aims to clarify what makes one type of commercial lease “best” or most suitable for a given situation. We will examine common lease structures, their pros and cons, and how to determine which arrangement aligns with your goals—whether you are a tenant seeking flexibility or a landlord aiming for stable returns. We will also consider who typically pays the costs associated with a commercial lease, what is considered a good length for a lease, and outline the primary obligations commercial landlords must meet.

By understanding these fundamentals, both landlords and tenants can approach negotiations more confidently, craft leases that reflect their interests and the realities of the market, and establish productive, long-term business relationships founded on mutual understanding.

Table of Contents

Types of Commercial Leases

Commercial leases come in various forms. The “best” type depends on factors like the nature of the tenant’s business, the property’s condition, market conditions, and risk appetite of both parties. While terminology and specific models can vary by country and region, some common types include:

1. Full Repairing and Insuring (FRI) Lease:
   Common in the UK, an FRI lease places most maintenance and repair responsibilities on the tenant. The tenant covers repairs, insurance, and upkeep, leaving the landlord with minimal direct property management costs. This can benefit landlords seeking a “hands-off” investment, while tenants must factor these additional expenses into their budgeting.

2. Triple-Net Lease (NNN Lease):
   Similar to FRI leases but more common in North America, a triple-net lease requires the tenant to pay rent plus property taxes, insurance premiums, and maintenance costs. The landlord’s role is largely limited to collecting rent and ensuring the property’s structural soundness. Tenants gain control over overhead costs, but also bear significant risk if expenses rise.

3. Modified Gross Lease (or Semi-Gross Lease):
   In a modified gross lease, the tenant pays a base rent and the landlord covers some property expenses, such as insurance and structural repairs. The tenant might pay utilities and interior maintenance, sharing cost burdens more evenly. This structure offers a balance: the tenant isn’t saddled with all external costs, while the landlord retains some responsibility and control.

4. Gross Lease (All-Inclusive Lease):
   Under a gross lease, the tenant pays a single, all-inclusive rent. The landlord handles property taxes, insurance, and maintenance out of that rent. This arrangement simplifies budgeting for tenants since they know their total cost upfront. Landlords assume the risk of rising expenses and must set rent accordingly to ensure profitability.

5. Short-Term or Flexible Leases (e.g., License to Occupy, Serviced Offices):
   These arrangements might not be full leases in a legal sense, sometimes referred to as licenses. They offer flexibility to tenants who need short-term or easily terminable arrangements. While higher in rent per square foot, they reduce long-term commitments and can be ideal for startups, seasonal businesses, or those testing a new market. Landlords benefit from premium rents and shorter-term deals but must accept higher turnover and uncertainty.

6. Turnover-Based or Percentage Leases:
   Common in retail scenarios, a tenant pays a base rent plus a percentage of their turnover. This can align the interests of both parties—a landlord confident in the property’s ability to drive customer traffic might accept a lower base rent for a share in the tenant’s success. Tenants benefit if their turnover is low, but pay more when business is strong.

Types of Commercial Leases: Which One Is For You?

Determining the “Best” Type of Commercial Lease

The “best” type of lease depends on the unique priorities and circumstances of the tenant and landlord:

• Tenant’s Perspective:
  A stable, established business might prefer an arrangement that provides cost certainty (like a gross lease) or predictable overheads. A newer venture wanting control over its space might pick a modified gross lease or a flexible agreement. If specialized equipment and fit-outs are involved, a longer lease might be beneficial. Those who want full control of repair and maintenance decisions might lean towards FRI or NNN leases.

• Landlord’s Perspective:
  Investors who want predictable returns without micromanaging expenses might prefer NNN or FRI leases to offload variable costs onto the tenant. A landlord unsure about the market’s stability might prefer shorter, more flexible leases allowing quick re-letting at higher rates. On the other hand, stable, long-term tenants with strong covenants might encourage the landlord to offer a longer lease term and a more balanced cost structure, such as a modified gross lease.

• Market Conditions:
  In a tenant’s market (high vacancy, lower demand), tenants can push for more favorable terms, like shorter leases or landlord-covered expenses. In a landlord’s market (low vacancy, strong demand), landlords can impose more NNN or FRI terms confident that tenants will accept these conditions.

In short, there is no one-size-fits-all “best” commercial lease. The ideal arrangement reflects the interplay between risk allocation, cost control, stability, and flexibility for both sides.

Who Pays the Cost of a Commercial Lease?

In commercial leases, the concept of “cost” extends beyond just rent. There are three main categories of costs:

1. Rent:
   The tenant always pays the rent. Rent is typically the fixed or base cost for occupying the premises. Under certain leases, rent may vary if it includes turnover-based components or periodic reviews.

2. Outgoings (Operating Expenses):
   Operating expenses can include property taxes, insurance, maintenance, repairs, utilities, and service charges for communal areas.

• Under an FRI or NNN lease, the tenant shoulders most outgoings.

• With a modified gross lease, some outgoings are split, with the landlord still covering structural or external maintenance and the tenant handling internal upkeep and utilities.

• With a gross lease, the landlord typically covers these outgoings out of the rent received, though rent will be set higher to account for these costs.

3. Upfront and Professional Fees:
   Costs such as solicitor’s fees, surveyor’s costs, and sometimes stamp duty land tax (in the UK) or similar transaction taxes may arise. Typically, each party pays their own legal costs, but this can vary by market tradition or negotiation. Fit-out costs, if not pre-agreed, might fall on the tenant. Some landlords offer rent-free periods or capital contributions to encourage the tenant to sign a longer lease.

In summary, Tenants always pay rent. Responsibility for other costs depends on the lease type. FRI/NNN leases push expenses to the tenant, whereas gross leases bundle them into a single rent. Modified gross leases strike a middle ground.

Commercial Tenants' Rights in the UK 2024

What Is a Good Commercial Lease Length?

Commercial lease terms vary widely. Common lengths range from 3 to 10 years, but both shorter and longer terms exist. What is “good” depends on:

• Stability vs. Flexibility for Tenants:
  A long-term lease (10+ years) provides security of location, helping brand building and reducing relocation costs. This suits well-established businesses confident in their site. However, a newer business might find a shorter term (3–5 years) more prudent, preserving flexibility and allowing easier relocation or downsizing if the business model changes.

• Stability vs. Market Responsiveness for Landlords:
  Landlords desiring stable rental income and less turnover might prefer longer leases with strong covenant tenants. This assures predictable revenue streams and reduces re-letting costs. If the market is rapidly appreciating, a landlord might favour shorter leases to re-price the rent sooner.

• Rent Review Clauses and Break Options:
  Leases often include rent reviews at intervals (every 3-5 years), adjusting rent to market levels. Break clauses let either party terminate the lease early under certain conditions, adding flexibility. A good lease length often involves a balance: a certain fixed period for stability plus periodic reviews and possibly a break clause to avoid unworkable long-term commitments.

• Future Business Plans:
  A tenant planning substantial fit-outs or customisations may want a longer lease to amortise those costs. A pop-up or seasonal business might prefer a license or very short lease of a few months.

In general: For a stable, established company, a 5–10 year lease (with breaks and reviews) may be “good.” For a startup, a shorter term (1–3 years) or flexible agreement might be wise to reduce risk.

Commercial Property Lease UK - Do’s and Don’ts in 2024

What Are the Obligations of a Commercial Landlord?

A commercial landlord’s obligations typically include:

1. Structural Repairs and Maintenance (unless passed to the tenant):
   Even under an FRI or NNN lease, landlords often retain responsibility for structural elements—roof, external walls, and load-bearing components. If the lease stipulates otherwise, the landlord must comply.

2. Ensuring Quiet Enjoyment:
   Landlords must allow tenants to use the premises without undue disturbance from the landlord or claims on the property. While they can inspect the property, they must give appropriate notice and not interfere with the tenant’s lawful activities.

3. Compliance with Health and Safety and Building Regulations:
   Landlords must ensure the property is safe, adheres to building codes, provides adequate fire safety measures, and meets any statutory obligations. While tenants handle internal compliance, the landlord addresses fundamental structural and environmental compliance aspects.

4. Providing Services (if agreed):
   If the lease includes landlord services (e.g., maintaining common areas, providing security, waste disposal), they must deliver these services at the standard agreed. Failure to do so could lead to disputes or claims for reduced rent or compensation.

5. Insurance:
   Landlords typically arrange building insurance to protect the property’s structure. In NNN or FRI leases, the tenant reimburses the premium, but the landlord must ensure coverage is in place. Adequate insurance is crucial to safeguarding both parties’ interests.

6. Rent Reviews and Lease Renewals:
   Landlords often have obligations related to rent review procedures, ensuring fairness and following established methods (like open-market rent comparisons). For business tenants with statutory renewal rights (under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 in England and Wales), the landlord has obligations to handle lease renewals properly.

7. Responding to Tenant’s Requests and Repairs:
   If the lease assigns certain repairs to the landlord (e.g., structural defects), the landlord must address these within a reasonable time. Ignoring maintenance requests can result in disputes or even legal action by the tenant.

Balancing Risk and Reward in Lease Negotiations

For both landlords and tenants, negotiating the type of lease is about striking a balance. Consider:

• For Tenants:
  The “best” lease is often one that provides predictable total costs, fair maintenance responsibilities, a suitable term length (with break clauses if needed), and clauses allowing for reasonable rent review processes. If a tenant wants less responsibility for unknown expenses, a gross or modified gross lease might be preferable, even if headline rent is higher.

• For Landlords:
  A “best” lease could be one that transfers as many costs as possible to the tenant (like an FRI/NNN arrangement), ensuring stable net returns. However, making the lease overly burdensome may deter quality tenants, reduce market competitiveness, or result in frequent turnover. Good landlords also consider reputation and stability over extracting every pound of profit.

Understanding the Legal Aspects of Subletting Commercial Properties in 2025

Considering Local Market Customs and Legal Advice

Commercial lease norms vary by country, region, and market. In the UK, for instance, FRI leases are common in certain sectors, whereas in other jurisdictions, modified gross or negotiated structures are the norm.

Always consult an experienced commercial property solicitor or agent. They can advise on:

• Prevailing local customs.

• Standard market terms for your industry or location.

• Whether certain clauses (e.g., rent-free periods, tenant improvement allowances) are common.

• How to approach rent reviews, break clauses, and dispute resolution mechanisms.

A solicitor ensures that the lease aligns with your commercial objectives, risk profile, and compliance with relevant property and tenancy laws.

Rent Reviews, Indexation, and Dispute Resolution

An important feature in many commercial leases is how rent is adjusted over time. Common mechanisms include:

• Open Market Rent Review:
  Periodic reviews (e.g., every 3 or 5 years) that set rent to current market levels. If the landlord and tenant disagree, an independent surveyor or arbitrator decides.

• Indexation:
  Linking rent to an inflation index (like RPI or CPI) to maintain rent’s real value over time. This provides predictability and saves on arbitration costs.

• Turnover Clauses:
  In retail, linking part of the rent to the tenant’s turnover can align interests and reduce disputes over market rent levels.

Dispute resolution clauses are also key. Many leases provide for arbitration, mediation, or expert determination if the landlord and tenant cannot agree on rent or other terms. This reduces lengthy litigation and maintains a more cooperative relationship.

Understanding Dilapidations in Commercial Leases: What Tenants Need to Know

Alterations, Assignments, and Subletting

Beyond rent and expenses, other lease terms influence how suitable a lease is:

• Alterations:
  Tenants often need to adapt premises to their business. Leases vary on whether landlord consent is needed, and if so, how easily it can be obtained. A lease that allows reasonable internal non-structural changes without excessive landlord red tape can be more attractive for certain tenants.

• Assignments and Subletting:
  The ability to assign or sublet affects lease flexibility. A tenant that foresees growth or change may want the right to assign the lease if they outgrow the space. Landlords typically want approval rights to ensure the assignee or subtenant is creditworthy.

• Options to Renew or Break Clauses:
  An option to renew at lease-end can be valuable if a tenant invests heavily in fit-outs. Break clauses provide flexibility, allowing the tenant (and sometimes the landlord) to terminate the lease early under certain conditions. Incorporating break clauses can make a longer lease more manageable, as tenants know they can exit if business conditions sour.

Minimising Disputes and Ensuring Compliance

Well-drafted leases clarify responsibilities, reducing the risk of disputes. Detailed schedules can specify who maintains which parts of the property, how insurance claims are handled, and the exact procedures for reporting and fixing repairs. The goal is to prevent ambiguity that leads to conflict.

Proactive communication between landlord and tenant also matters. A landlord fulfilling obligations promptly and a tenant reporting issues early and maintaining the property responsibly can foster a harmonious landlord-tenant relationship.

Legal Consequences of Breaking a Commercial Lease

Changing Market Dynamics and the Future of Commercial Leasing

E-commerce growth, remote work, and evolving consumer habits have shaken traditional office and retail sectors. Landlords and tenants are increasingly exploring flexible arrangements, shorter terms, shared workspace models, or leases with break clauses aligned to business cycles.

Green leases, incorporating sustainability targets and energy efficiency requirements, are also emerging. Both parties benefit from lower costs and enhanced corporate social responsibility. Future leases may tie rent or incentives to environmental performance metrics.

As the commercial real estate landscape evolves, so does the concept of the “best” lease. Adaptability, transparency, and collaborative negotiation are likely to remain central principles.

Leasing vs. Buying Commercial Property: Which is Better for Your Business?

Additional FAQs

Q: Do I need a solicitor to negotiate a commercial lease?

A: While not legally mandatory, it is highly advisable. A solicitor ensures the lease terms are fair, lawful, and aligned with your business interests, preventing costly mistakes and misunderstandings.

Q: Can a commercial lease be terminated early?

A: If the lease includes a break clause, a tenant or landlord can end the lease at a specified time by giving proper notice. Otherwise, early termination usually requires negotiation, potentially involving surrender premiums or finding a suitable assignee.

Q: What happens if the tenant defaults on rent payments?

A: The lease typically outlines remedies: interest on late payments, forfeiture (landlord regains possession), or legal action to recover owed amounts. Many landlords prefer negotiation to maintain occupancy rather than immediate forfeiture.

Q: Do I need insurance as a tenant?

A: Tenants often must insure their contents and public liability while the landlord insures the building. The lease can specify insurance responsibilities. Check that you understand who covers what and consider additional coverage if needed.

Q: How is a commercial lease valued?

Valuing a commercial lease typically involves assessing the rent and the terms (length, repair obligations, rent review clauses, and tenant’s covenant strength) relative to market conditions. Key factors include:

• Market Comparable: Comparing rent for similar properties in the same location.

• Property Condition & Specification: High-quality fit-outs, good location, parking, and transport links can enhance rental value.

• Length & Security of Tenure: Longer leases with strong tenants can command higher rents, as they represent stable income.

• Tenant Covenant Strength: A financially robust tenant might justify a premium because it reduces the landlord’s risk of default.
  Valuers often use yield-based calculations, comparing annual rent to prevailing investment yields, and consider incentives like rent-free periods.

Q: How much does it cost to set up a lease?

Costs vary widely depending on complexity, location, and professional fees. Typical expenses include:

• Solicitor Fees: For drafting and negotiating the lease. Costs can range from a few hundred to several thousand pounds.

• Surveyor’s Fees: If a valuation or condition report is needed.

• Stamp Duty Land Tax (if applicable): In the UK, you may owe SDLT on lease premiums or high annual rents.

• Registration Costs: For leases over 7 years, registration with HM Land Registry is required, incurring registration fees.
  In total, setting up a lease might cost anywhere from a few hundred to several thousand pounds, depending on complexity.

Q: What is a good commercial lease length?

A “good” lease length depends on the parties’ objectives:

• Longer Terms (5–10 years or more): Suitable for established businesses wanting security and stability or landlords seeking guaranteed income.

• Shorter Terms (1–5 years): Better for new or uncertain businesses, offering flexibility and lower risk if the location proves unsuitable.
  Many prefer a balance: a 5-year lease with a break clause at year 3, for example, providing some stability with an option to terminate early if needed.

Q: Who pays commercial property insurance?

Typically, the landlord arranges building insurance for the property’s structure. Under FRI or NNN-style leases, the tenant reimburses these insurance premiums. In other lease types, the landlord may absorb the insurance cost as part of a higher inclusive rent. Check the lease terms: who bears the insurance cost and how it is recovered should be clearly stated.

Q: How to calculate the rental value of a commercial property?

Rental value is often calculated by comparing rents of similar properties (comparable method) and considering:

• Location quality, footfall, and visibility.

• Property size, layout, and amenities.

• Condition and specification (modern interiors, energy efficiency).

• Lease terms (length, tenant’s responsibility for repairs, break clauses).
  Surveyors might also use income-based methods: applying yields to expected rents to align with market norms.

Q: How does commercial leasehold work?

Leasehold means the tenant (leaseholder) has the right to occupy and use the property for the lease term while the landlord (freeholder) retains ownership. The lease details each party’s rights and obligations, including rent payment, maintenance responsibilities, rights of assignment or subletting, and dispute resolution mechanisms. Once the lease expires, rights typically revert to the landlord unless renewed.

Q: Is a commercial lease valid if not signed by tenant?

Generally, a lease must be signed by both parties to be legally binding. However, if a tenant takes possession and pays rent, a tenancy at will or periodic tenancy might arise by conduct. Without a signed formal lease, certain protections or obligations may not fully apply. It’s always best for both parties to execute the lease in writing and have all signatures properly witnessed.

Q: What is the 5-year rule in the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954?

Under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (in England and Wales), business tenants often have a right to renew their lease. Historically, certain rights and procedures were activated after the tenant occupied the premises for at least 5 years. However, since amendments, the key factor is whether the tenancy is “contracted out” of the Act’s protection or not. If not contracted out, the tenant may have statutory renewal rights. The “5 year rule” informally refers to conditions under old practices or misunderstandings. Modernly, rights can arise if the tenancy is protected and the tenant occupies for business purposes continuously. Always check the current provisions of the Act and seek legal advice.

Q: Can the landlord terminate a commercial lease agreement?

Landlords cannot usually unilaterally end a fixed-term lease early unless:

• The lease includes a landlord’s break clause, exercisable under set conditions.

• The tenant breaches terms significantly (e.g., persistent non-payment of rent, unauthorised alterations). The landlord may then seek forfeiture.
  For leases protected under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, termination at expiry or refusal to renew requires specific statutory grounds. Without these conditions, the landlord must wait until the term ends or renegotiate.

Q: What happens if I don’t register a lease?

In England and Wales, leases granted for more than 7 years must be registered at HM Land Registry. Failure to register means:

• The lease does not attain full legal status, though it may remain enforceable as a contractual agreement.

• Certain property rights and protections might not apply.

• Future assignments or financing may be complicated because the unregistered lease is less secure.
  Always register leases over 7 years to ensure maximum legal protection and marketability.

Q: Can a freeholder refuse to extend a lease?

For residential lease extensions, leaseholders have statutory rights to extend if certain conditions are met. For commercial leases, extension depends on negotiation or statutory renewal rights under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954. If the Act applies and the tenant has rights, the landlord can refuse renewal only on specified statutory grounds (e.g., redevelopment or tenant’s serious breaches). Without statutory rights, the landlord is free to refuse extension, forcing the tenant to vacate upon lease expiry.

Why Choose Moeen & Co. Solicitors

For anyone navigating the complexities of a commercial lease—whether as landlord or tenant—expert legal advice is invaluable. Moeen & Co. Solicitors offers:

1. Specialised Expertise in Commercial Property:
   Our firm’s solicitors have deep knowledge of commercial real estate law and best practices, enabling them to advise on lease structures, negotiations, and dispute resolutions.

2. Personalised Guidance:
   We take time to understand your goals, risk tolerance, and business model. We tailor recommendations for the type and length of lease, cost allocations, and clauses that protect your interests.

3. Cost-Effective Solutions:
   Our approach seeks balanced outcomes. If you’re a tenant, we aim to secure favorable terms and avoid hidden pitfalls. If you’re a landlord, we help craft a lease that enhances investment returns and stability.

4. Clear Communication and Transparency:
   We explain complex legal terms in plain English, ensuring you understand every clause. We keep you informed, respond promptly, and work collaboratively throughout the process.

5. Dispute Resolution and Future Support:
   Should disagreements arise later, we can represent you in rent reviews, maintenance disputes, or lease renewal negotiations. Our long-term approach ensures ongoing support and strategic insights.

By choosing Moeen & Co. Solicitors, you gain advocates who prioritize clarity, fairness, and your commercial success. We strive to make commercial leasing less intimidating and more profitable for our clients.

Conclusion

Selecting the “best” type of commercial lease depends on multiple factors: the tenant’s business needs, the landlord’s investment strategy, market conditions, and local customs. Tenants seeking predictability might prefer a gross or modified gross lease, while landlords wanting minimal expense exposure lean toward full repairing and insuring or triple-net structures. Negotiations must balance cost-sharing, risk, lease length, and flexibility.

Who pays the costs of a commercial lease, what constitutes a “good” lease length, and understanding each party’s obligations are all integral aspects of shaping a suitable arrangement. Clear definitions of responsibilities—particularly concerning repairs, insurance, and service charges—reduce misunderstandings.

A well-considered lease benefits both sides. Tenants gain stability and cost predictability, while landlords secure reliable income and maintain property value. By seeking professional legal advice, considering the unique circumstances of both parties and staying informed about evolving market conditions, you can craft or select a commercial lease that aligns with your objectives and lays the foundation for a productive, long-term commercial tenancy relationship.

With Moeen & Co. Solicitors by your side, you have knowledgeable professionals guiding you through these complex decisions, ensuring that your chosen lease is not just acceptable but optimal for your commercial aspirations.